Compensation measures (aptitude test or adaptation period)
Definition
Compensation measures are the aptitude test or adaptation period that a licensing authority can require when your training differs substantially from what it requires. Under Directive 2005/36/EC they must be justified and proportionate, an adaptation period can last up to three years, and you can usually choose which one to take.
Also called: compensation measure, Ausgleichsmaßnahme, Anpassungsmaßnahme, compensation measures NMBI, medidas compensatorias
Checked against official sources on
What are compensation measures?
When an authority compares your training with its own and finds substantial differences, it can still recognise you once you have made up for them. Article 14 of Directive 2005/36/EC allows two measures:
- An aptitude test: an exam limited to the subjects where your training fell short, which must take account of the fact that you are already qualified (Article 3(1)(h)).
- An adaptation period: supervised practice of up to three years, possibly with further training, followed by an assessment (Article 3(1)(g)).
Germany's recognition portal describes compensation measures the same way: they let you make up the substantial differences so that you can still receive full recognition.
When can an authority impose one?
Only where your training covers substantially different matters, meaning knowledge and skills essential to the profession where the content differs significantly (Article 14(4)). The authority must first check whether your professional experience or formally validated lifelong learning covers the gap (Article 14(5)). The decision must give the levels of qualification, the differences and the reasons experience does not compensate (Article 14(6)).
Do you get to choose?
Usually yes: Article 14(2) gives you the choice between the two. The host country may instead decide which measure applies for some groups, including doctors and dentists recognised under the general system and holders of a third-country qualification under Article 3(3). If an aptitude test is imposed, you must be able to sit it within six months of the decision (Article 14(7)).
How countries apply them to non-EU training
- Germany, doctors: third-country applicants prove their knowledge by passing the Kenntnisprüfung, a test on the content of the state exam (Bundesärzteordnung, section 3).
- Germany, nurses: the Pflegeberufegesetz (section 40) gives you the right to choose between a Kenntnisprüfung and an adaptation course of up to three years ending in an exam.
- Ireland, nurses and midwives: NMBI can set an aptitude test or a period of adaptation and assessment, explained in our NMBI compensation measures guide.
- Spain: a homologación can be granted on condition that you complete complementary training, which may include an aptitude test, within four years.
Common problems
- Reading the wrong measure into the notice. An aptitude test (Eignungsprüfung) covers only the listed gaps; Germany's Kenntnisprüfung for third-country applicants relates to the whole state exam. Check which one your decision names.
- Waiting too long. Exam dates and adaptation places can be scarce, and some decisions carry time limits, so start arranging the measure as soon as you receive it.
- Language. Passing a compensation measure does not replace the separate language requirement for the licence.
How to complete a compensation measure
- Read the decision, often called a Defizitbescheid in Germany, and note each difference listed.
- Tell the authority which measure you choose, where you have a choice.
- Find a test date or an adaptation placement. In Germany the notice sometimes names providers, and free counselling centres can help.
- Submit the pass certificate to the authority, which then checks the remaining conditions, such as language and fitness to practise.
Questions
Not exactly. An aptitude test (Eignungsprüfung) covers only the subjects where differences were found and is used for EU-trained applicants. The Kenntnisprüfung is the German test for third-country applicants and relates to the content of the full state exam.
It depends on your situation. A test can be quicker if you prepare well, while an adaptation period lets you work under supervision but can last up to three years. Where you have a choice, ask the authority and a counselling centre about available dates and placements before deciding.
Yes. Under Article 14(5) the authority must check whether your professional experience or validated lifelong learning covers the differences before imposing a measure. In Germany the laws for doctors and nurses contain the same rule.
The directive does not set one deadline for applicants. National rules and individual decisions do, for example Spain's four-year limit for complementary training. Check the time limits stated in your decision.
Yes. Under the directive the decision must be reasoned and can be challenged under national law. German notices include instructions on how to appeal (Rechtsbehelfsbelehrung).
Yes. NMBI can require an aptitude test or a period of adaptation and assessment where it finds gaps in your training. Our NMBI guide explains both options.
Sources
- 1Directive 2005/36/EC on the recognition of professional qualifications, consolidated text (EUR-Lex)
- 2European Commission: general system of recognition
- 3Anerkennung in Deutschland: glossary
- 4Anerkennung in Deutschland: what happens after the notice
- 5Bundesärzteordnung, section 3 (gesetze-im-internet.de)
- 6Pflegeberufegesetz, section 40 (gesetze-im-internet.de)
- 7Real Decreto 889/2022, de 18 de octubre (BOE)